← The Found Photo

The Found Photo · No. 02 · August 2, 2026

After the Earthquake

By Cybele Peña

A large group of survivors of the 1900 earthquake posing for the camera at El Guamacho, La Guaira.
C. D. Nelaton · “La Guaira: Tiendas de campaña en ‘El Guamacho’” · El Cojo Ilustrado, 1900

The crossing of gazes is one of the most liminal experiences we have before photographs from other eras. A silent negotiation takes place between the photographer’s intention, the sitters who return our gaze, and the position of those of us who look from the present. In this crossing of times, a group of survivors from the turn of the century comes into view. The image belongs to a series of views that El Cojo Ilustrado devoted to the aftermath of the San Narciso earthquake, which struck in the early hours of October 29, 1900, and severely affected Caracas, Guatire, and the coast. In “La Guaira: Tents in ‘El Guamacho’,” the tension between catastrophe and the neatness of the clothes, the choral arrangement, and the steady gazes before C. D. Nelaton’s camera place us before a ceremonious, painterly staging.

The image is almost a regents’ group portrait. It reveals how much institutional photography inherited from salon painting, not only in its compositional rigor but in its ideological function. The instrumentalization of photography would come to define a social body that is also political. Here, the photograph offers a grand portrait of the population preserved by state relief and charitable organizations. The group is catalogued by age and gender: the youngest in front, boys on the left, girls and babies in the foreground. A man in a bow tie stands out, surely an important benefactor. Behind them, other adults from the camp adopt postures of assistance and order. The people of El Guamacho have been dressed with a clear symbolic intention. Girls and women wear a single style of white dress, which conveys the ideals of beauty and hygiene that nineteenth-century English fashions had consolidated around childhood. The boys, too, have been carefully put in uniform. Everything is in tune with a larger discourse on the modern state as guarantor of the health and progress of races and nations. When Nelaton photographs El Guamacho in 1900, he is legitimizing the official response to the emergency. It is photography telling the reader that authority responds, and provides order, dignity, and continuity.

The photograph responds to an idealized projection in which order has been restored within the image. But because the camera captures far more than it controls, it also records its own optical unconscious. Some of the boys have outgrown their jackets. On the left, there may be a vanishing point that escaped Nelaton: a grayish boy without a uniform peers out from between the beams. Nor does the order of the photograph reveal what nights were like in El Guamacho, or how the tents actually held up against the elements. And yet, in the group portrait, the living gaze of a kind of collective resilience also slips through: a portrayed dignity that conveys unity and coherence between those who came to the rescue and the real preservation of those who survive. As an act of documentation and legacy, the photograph reminds us of the now lost place of governance in the face of geology’s inevitable ruptures, as the harrowing scene left by the earthquake that struck Venezuela on June 24, 2026, attests: there, the ruling power could not even feign a symbolic protection. The photograph of the camp, and the collective that now looks at us, also reveal allegorical dimensions. They could be the altarpiece of a choir of angels, or a monument to our forebears, with colonial La Guaira in the background and the Ávila on its most radiant morning.

Originally published in Spanish in Papel Literario, El Nacional, on August 2, 2026. Read in El Nacional (Spanish) →