But isn’t every square inch of our cities a crime scene? Every passer-by a culprit? Isn’t it the task of the photographer – descendant of the augurs and haruspices – to reveal guilt and to point out the guilty in his pictures?
Walter Benjamin
Photography in the twentieth-century album is usually associated with some romantic dimension of memory’s milestones: a wedding, a birthday, a birth, or an official gala. Miguel Villavicencio’s album, however, offers a different showcase. It is a photographic weave of almost three thousand portraits of people detained in Caracas in the late 1940s. The photographs form a mosaic of faces that are hard to identify from the album alone. Opening it entails, a priori, a kind of forensic archaeology. One must not only leaf through it wearing nitrile gloves, but also read it with a detective’s eye, deciphering textual and material clues. At first glance, the monumental album is an encrypted photographic cemetery. Yet its photographs, observed up close, form a human gallery that looks back at us, unsettlingly alive.
The handwritten cover—“Property of citizen Miguel Villavicencio. Caracas, 1948”—together with photographs of officers holding flashlights, confirms that we stand before an archive produced and managed by the law. I tracked down his grandson and namesake, who confirmed that his grandfather, Miguel Segundo Villavicencio, had indeed been a police officer from Churuguara who worked in several Venezuelan cities. In the album, the officer’s name suggests a kind of archon and Big Brother of the operational archive. The pages convey a sense of order in which each photograph, cropped in much the same way, becomes comparable and analogous. This seriality is reinforced by an editorial design that replicates a disciplinary architecture of panoptic cells, standardizing the faces into a legible grid. Benjamin had already linked photographic practice to the police function. Police photography, precisely, strips the subject of subjectivity, folding gaze and face into a police file. In the police album, citizens can be scrutinized through physiognomic readings that respond to the desire to visualize, study, and control criminal otherness.
Under what material conditions were these images produced? What practices took shape around this photographic project? Seen up close, the photographs do not come from a single camera, do not share the same background, and do not follow a single printing process. This material heterogeneity extends to the diverse catalog of people classified by the police lens in mid-century Caracas. The album shows what the police lens classified as different racial types, women and men of various ages, better or worse dressed; even children inhabit the criminal archive. Among blurred inscriptions, lively nicknames slip through: “El Chino Fernández,” “Petróleo Crudo” (Crude Oil), “El Caliente” (The Hot One). There are dates: 20-3-47 for man 000151, and another, relatively distant one for 000157: 9-4-48. The young man 574[…] became illegible, a missing link in this photographic Babel. Might these numbers correspond to names traceable in some national archive? How could we locate the humanity of child 5738? Then as now, the identity of those confined seems to wait, suspended, in a zone of shadow—a limbo of anonymity and emptiness that the public gaze cannot always enter. And yet, in the surviving album, the printed photograph is also an irreplaceable material trace. As Barthes observed of the analog camera, the photograph attests that a body was there. Despite the incomplete record, each portrait casts a bridge of memory and is an act of presence of those who are no longer here.
Originally published in Spanish in Papel Literario, El Nacional, on July 5, 2026. Read in El Nacional (Spanish) →
